Published on: April 24, 2025
It is a new year and with that comes a new top 5! We try to keep you updated with all the newest products on the market because there are just so many to choose from! This time around we are tackling eye serums. If you are like most, then you can agree that the first signs of aging usually start around your eyes with fine lines, wrinkles, puffiness, dark circles, crow’s feet, and even saggy skin.
Adding to aging one sleepless night or stress, this delicate area is not so forgiving, and it may take a while before the puffiness disappears. Some may be asking what is better, eye cream or eye serum? At first glance, the two may seem very much alike, but we have found that there are a few characteristics that make them different.
Both the eye cream and eye serum tend to moisturize. However, while eye creams occasionally help with dark circles and fine lines, eye serums tend to help more effectively with those stubborn fine lines and dark circles. The eye serum is far more powerful, and we recommend that you look out for two powerhouse components. Caffeine and Vitamin C.
Due to the sensitivity that is around the eye area, it is imperative to pick the best one for you. Try to look at the ingredients listed on the product and make sure that most of them are natural and have no fillers. If you have sensitive skin, we recommend using a fragrance–free product. There are some that really do work and others not listed that did not do it for us.
Here are the Top 5 that our researchers picked:
Melissa Alvarez
Senior Editor - Beauty Specialist
I work as a beauty specialist, doing extensive research for non-profit beauty organizations. I would love to share my findings, which were acquired by carefully examining each product, their results, and side effects if any. I've ranked them based on these findings.
2024’s TOP RATED EYE SERUMS
#1 Gle Skincare for Dark Circles
#2 CLINIQUE All About Eyes
#3 La Mer The Lifting Eye Serum
#4 Murad Retinol Youth Renewal Eye Serum
#5 Restorative Eye Crème Anti-Aging Neuropeptide Eye Cream
#1 Glè for Dark Circles
(15ML 0.51 FL OZ)
5.0
Our Rating: 9.5/10
Customer Rating: 9.68/10 (256 Votes)
This product is from a 3-step bundle that you can purchase separately, of course. What we love about this serum is that it is a clear, slick texture that seems to absorb into the skin rather quickly, so there is no need to wait before you proceed with your routine. This serum must be used in the morning and at night to achieve the results that you want. You can see it working from the moment that you apply it underneath and around the eyes. This serum contains all-natural ingredients. The two key ingredients here are Caffeine and Vitamin C.
Vitamin C– this is a powerful antioxidant that stimulates the production of collagen that has decreased due to aging. This vitamin will also help protect your skin from future damaging of skin from the sun and other free radicals. This can also help with pigmentation and hydration.
Caffeine – This has become an extremely popular ingredient in anti-aging. Packed with antioxidants and anti-inflammatories, it has been proven to reduce the appearance of dark circles around the eye area. Caffeine helps make the skin come alive with brightness. it will reduce puffiness and darkness linked with dark circles.
Availability
LOW STOCK
Update: The special offer expires April 24, 2025
OVERALL GRADE
A +
POSITIVES
Contains all-natural ingredients
Suitable for most skin types
Fragrance-free
Cruelty-free
Rich in antioxidants
Made in the USA
Hydrates the sensitive area around the eyes
Reduces the appearance of wrinkles
Tackles that under-eye puffiness
Unisex product
Brand was featured on:
NEGATIVES
Due to popularity, sometimes it’s on backorder/sold out
Update: The special offer expires April 24, 2025
I work long hours, and about 5 years ago, I started noticing some dark circles forming under my eyes. I panicked and started purchasing products all over the place, trying to find the right one. They all overpromised and underdelivered. I like this product because it has all the important ingredients that work for me and also it's reasonably priced, unlike most products on the market.
See moreI wasn't offered any kind of compensation for this review. At 68 years old I can testify that I am an experienced skin care shopper. I purchased many expensive facial skin brands; I also tried "all natural" unknown brands online and inexpensive drugstore sold facial creams and I have never found a skin care line in the likes of "Gle Skincare" Gle Serum for dark circles delivers what they promise. My skin has never looked this beautiful since before I began my menopausal years. My pores are shrinking, and my wrinkles are gently smoothing out. It is by far the very best skin care line on the market. My two daughters who are young moms have begun using Gle Skincare products and several of my "mature" friends have begun using this line as well. I suggest you begin with the Gle Anti-Aging Bundleand go from there. You will notice a significant improvement within just a couple of weeks. I have absolutely nothing to gain by writing this positive review. I just want to share with you my experience with the Gle Skincare products and hopefully you can benefit from it if too. You will not regret it, I promise.
See moreI am in my 40s, but look young for my age. Eye creams usually seem like a waste of time to me and even though I use a ton of products I often skip eye stuff. I decided to try this, and I actually really like. I really do feel like it works. It goes on really well and I really, really like it.
See moreI tried the product about 6 months ago when my sister gave it to me as a birthday gift. We are identical twins and I've always turned to her for skincare advice. She looks much younger than me. I did some research on my own and it looks like the vitamin c and caffeine serums really work for a lot of people. I am a regular customer now! The price is also great.
See moreI really like the product, but I have to be honest! It takes a little bit of time. When I first started using the product, I didn't see results until at least a month and a half later. The product feels nice and it's really smoothening the skin in the eye area. I am very sensitive to smells and fragrances so that's another reason why I stuck with this product!
See moreGreat price for an eye cream that is gentle on sensitive skin and effective moisturizing the delicate eye area.
See moreThis product is perfect for my sensitive dry skin and it's scent-free. Normally I get a rash from almost any eye serum. I was pleasantly surprised to see that this one doesn't give me any issues. It's a hassle to find an effective product that works with my skin so I am grateful I found this one!
See more#2 CLINIQUE All About Eyes
(15ML 0.5 FL OZ)
4.7
Our Rating: 8.5/10
Customer Rating: 8.68/10 (200 Votes)
We are positive that you have heard or even used something from this company at one point or another. CLINIQUE is famous for its fragrance-free creams, serums, and moisturizers. What we loved about this product is the fact that it is a fast-absorbing formula that hydrates the skin as well as tightens it. This serum is oil-free as well. Gentle enough for twice-daily use. Our researchers discovered that although this serum does moisturize the skin around the eye, it does not tackle many anti-aging issues.
OVERALL GRADE
B +
POSITIVES
Fragrance-free product, great for sensitive skin
Unisex
Hydrates
Fast absorbing
NEGATIVES
Not a cruelty-free product
Does not tackle anti-aging issues
Many noticed a burning sensation in their eyes after applying
#3 La Mer The Lifting Eye Serum
(15ML 0.5 FL OZ)
4.2
Our Rating: 7.5/10
Customer Rating: 7.68/10 (193 Votes)
This serum is particularly good at reducing the appearance of red, puffy, and tired eyes. It will give you an instant lift. With that being said, this feeling does not last long, and we didn’t find it to prevent any new wrinkles from appearing. La Mer is on the pricey side, so we did not think that the price justifies the product although we did like the texture of it.
OVERALL GRADE
B –
POSITIVES
Works immediately to remove puffy and dark circles
The texture is great and hydrates
Good for any skin type
Lightweight
NEGATIVES
The product is a bit pricey. We found that for less money we can achieve the same or even better results with Gle for Dark Circles
Doesn’t moisturize as much as expected to
This product does not combat puffiness and dark circles.
#4. Murad Retinol Youth Renewal Eye Serum
(30ML 1 FL OZ)
4.0
Our Rating: 6.8/10
Customer Rating: 6.95/10 (154 Votes)
This serum is recommended for all ages and is good to prevent wrinkles in younger skin as well. What caught our eye here was the retinol. The amount included is just enough to make a slight difference in the skin’s texture and appearance.
This serum is ophthalmologist tested and will not burn the eyes if accidentally goes in during application. Can be used on all skin types, even combination skin. Murad Serum does not contain parabens or sulfates.
OVERALL GRADE
C +
POSITIVES
Contains retinol
Firms and tighten the saggy skin under the eyes
Cruelty-free
A little goes a long way, the product will last a while
NEGATIVES
Can only use at night because it contains retinol so you will need to purchase another day serum.
Some users complained about the dispensing. The pump kept getting stuck.
#5. Restorative Eye Crème Anti-Aging Neuropeptide Eye Cream
(15ML 0.5 FL OZ)
3.9
Our Rating: 6.1/10
Customer Rating: 5.95/10 (141 Votes)
Now That is a long name! This serum is packed with antioxidants that are known for repairing free radical damage. Meaning, it is working constantly to protect your skin from UV rays, and cell damage.
The mango seed butter is included for its moisturizing properties and the added peptides are the ones that help reduce the appearance of fine lines and puffiness. We did not love the fact that the bottle is only 15ml and the price tag is high.
OVERALL GRADE
C –
POSITIVES
Contains many antioxidants to assist with cellular health
The skin seemed plumper after using
Contains a light fragrance
NEGATIVES
Unclear whether this company conducts animal testing.
Fragrance and other added oils caused irritation in most users.
Slight results but after a long period of time.
Not for every budget.